The People of the State of Michigan - - - (Complainants) VS William Shimmel - - - (Defendant) |
Thomas McCarthy Cross Examination |
|
Page 97 |
|
|
Q |
After that? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Stayed there some little time? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
And every day up to the time of the funeral? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
And after the funeral was over on Friday that was ten o’clock I suppose? |
A |
Yes, sir, about that. |
|
|
Q |
Did you go back to Golden’s house after that? |
A |
No, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Have you been back there since? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
When was you there last? |
A |
I was there on Sunday night after it happened. |
|
|
Q |
Was that the last time you were there? |
A |
Yes, sir, while they lived there. |
|
|
Q |
Well how long did they live there? |
A |
Well they only lived there a few days, they didn’t stay and live in the house there, they went to Coopersville a few nights after that. |
|
|
Q |
How many days would you say - - a week, did she stay there a week after the funeral? |
A |
No, I ‘aint sure, but I don’t think they stayed in the house only one night after that. |
|
|
Q |
Did she have some relatives living in Coopersville? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
What relatives were they? |
|
|
|
Page 98 |
|
|
A |
Her mother and sister. |
|
|
Q |
And she went down there? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Now you think that they only stayed there one night after the funeral? |
A |
Well I ‘aint positive but I think that is all that they stayed in the house. |
|
|
Q |
Then you were there on Sunday night were you? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
What did you go back Sunday night for? |
A |
I went back with her brother, he wanted to get something out of the house? |
|
|
Q |
And you went back and assisted him in getting it? |
A |
I didn’t go in the house, no. He got what he wanted. |
|
|
Q |
You went down to the house with him? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Have you seen Mrs. Golden since she moved to Coopersville? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
When did you see her after that? |
A |
I saw her several times. |
|
|
Q |
Talked with her? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Is she friendly and all right? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Is she just as friendly as she ever was? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
When did you see Mrs. Golden last? |
A |
I saw her to-day. |
|
|
|
Page 99 |
|
|
Q |
To-day? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
When did you see her outside of to-day? |
A |
I saw her yesterday. |
|
|
Q |
You saw her here do you mean? |
A |
Yesterday, I saw her yesterday. |
|
|
Q |
Where did you see her yesterday? |
A |
Church. |
|
|
Q |
Down there at the church that you go to? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Did you see her last Sunday? |
A |
No, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Did you talk with her when you met her at church? |
A |
Just spoke is all. |
|
|
Q |
Now did you ever see this man Shimmel before that night? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Where did you see him? |
A |
I saw him up in the town of Ravenna at Mrs. Zoles. |
|
|
Q |
What does Mr. Zoles do, is he a farmer? |
A |
He was a farmer. |
|
|
Q |
And what were you doing up there? |
A |
I was visiting my sister. |
|
|
Q |
Does you sister lie up there? |
A |
She is married to Andrew Zoles. |
|
|
Q |
What was Shimmel doing up there? |
A |
He come there to spend the evening, they were playing Pedro. |
|
|
Q |
At Zoles? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
Page 100 |
|
|
Q |
How long ago was that? |
A |
That was about or twenty one years ago I should think, somewheres around there I don’t know exactly, but it is pretty close to that. |
|
|
Q |
Was that the last time you had seen him since this time? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
So that you can really say that you were acquainted with him? |
A |
Well I wasn’t acquainted enough to speak to him, I just see him there one night, I think one evening. |
|
|
Q |
And did he look just about as he does now? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Hasn’t made any change in twenty-one years? |
A |
Older and he is not as heavy I don’t think. |
|
|
Q |
Did he have any beard or mustache at that time? |
A |
Well it was shaved off, only about a weeks growth on when I saw him. |
|
|
Q |
About a weeks growth? |
A |
Yes, sir. Had a mustache. |
|
|
Q |
And a beard? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
You think he was heavier at that time? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
And you never saw him again until you thought it might have been him that night? |
A |
Well I didn’t think it was him. |
|
|
Q |
Well I know, but afterwards you thought it might have been him didn’t you? |
A |
I thought it might have been him. |
|
|
|
Page 101 |
|
|
Q |
Now there is one thing that I omitted. Did anybody ask you there that night when the shooting occurred why you didn’t go and try to find this man and get him and stop him? |
A |
Yes, sir. |
|
|
Q |
Who asked you? |
A |
L.D. Taylor. |
|
|
Q |
Who is he? |
A |
He is deputy sheriff there at Coopersville. |
|
|
Q |
What did you tell him? |
A |
I told him we didn’t have any right to stop him and what would we stop him for. |
|
|
Q |
You knew that you did have a right to stop him, didn’t you? |
A |
No, sir, I didn’t know any such thing. |
|
|
Q |
If a man would kill your brother wouldn’t you detain him until a man arrived that could take him into custody? |
A |
We didn’t know that he had done anything then, exactly. |
|
|
Q |
You didn’t know that he had done anything exactly, but you imagined that he did from the statements you made to me, didn’t you. |
A |
That was afterwards. |
|
|
Q |
After the shooting you said, somebody has been trying to hold Mart up and he has shot at him and then you afterwards before he got to you - - |
A |
(Interrupting) I said that Mart shot at him. |
|
|
Q |
I know, and after that before he got to you, you said, if that man done the shooting we want to look out. |
A |
Yes, sir, I said it. |
|
|
Q |
Now the reason you didn’t stop him was because you wanted to |